Sara Thompson returns to her hometown to help her mother move and is surprised to find her ex-boyfriend Josh Hartman is back home. The two had once planned a life in music together but Sara left to study law. The former flames slowly reconnect and try to heal wounds, both old and new. When Sara makes a surprising discovery, she and Josh forge a bold plan for the upcoming Christmas concert that will lead them all back to their musical roots and make this a holiday to remember.
Unfortunately the movie When I Think of Christmas is not yet available on HBO Max.
| Directing | Peter Benson | Director |
| Writing | Blythe Robe | Writer |
| Writing | Mike Robe | Writer |
| Production | Charles Cooper | Producer |
| Production | Harvey Kahn | Executive Producer |
| Production | Stephanie Germain | Executive Producer |
| Production | Allen Lewis | Co-Executive Producer |
| Production | Arielle Port | Co-Executive Producer |
| Production | Michael Shepard | Co-Executive Producer |
| Camera | William McKnight | Director of Photography |
| Production | Trevor Belcourt | Production Designer |
| Editing | Emerson Hill | Editor |
| Sound | Sean William | Music |
| Production | Jackie Lind | Casting |
